Post printed resumes and cover letters around the room. Students circulate with sticky notes using a simple code: green for strengths, blue for clarifying questions, orange for suggestions. Limiting comments to evidence and impact reduces noise. A debrief converts observations into actionable, prioritized revision goals.
Share short narratives behind improved bullets and paragraphs: what felt unclear, which advice mattered, and how results changed. Students learn that strong writing rarely appears in one draft. Hearing peers describe missteps normalizes struggle, builds trust, and inspires braver choices in language, format, and detail.
Use criteria written as student-facing success statements: clarity, alignment to posting, evidence of results, and professional tone. Pair each level with examples. When rubrics double as checklists, learners can self-assess, set targets, and request feedback precisely, making grading transparent and reinforcing a coaching culture.